When director nick son of john cassavetes went to work on john q, im sure his heart was in the right place. The true story of pocahontas history smithsonian magazine. John q movie analysis essay 1239 words 5 pages the movie john q narrates a story of the financially constrained character john quincy archibald who ensures that his nine year old son at the brink of death, secures a heart transplant by any means possible. Archibald is not a real person, but the lead character in the movie called john q. If the movie john q is not based on a true story then who is. The article noted that various funding sources are available for. Film hit close to home for nick cassavetes directors young daughter has heart disease like the boy in his thriller john q. But thats what denzel washingtons character does in the film john q. However gripping and terrifying you found bravos thriller series dirty john, its nothing compared to the real life story that inspired the show. Archibald, an american factory worker that has been the victim of a declining economy, and is faced with the difficulty of paying for medical services when his son is struck down at a baseball game with heart failure due to a congenital defect. As the movie begins, we are introduced to john, his wife, denise. Denzels acting was great but disappointed with the ending because of a few loose ends eg. How long do you suppose john q s prison sentence was.
A 31yearold serving his second sentence for armed robbery in california develops a viral. He accepted this job because, with his daughter sasha on a donated organ recipient list, he felt a connection with the characters and situations presented in the movie. They also mentioned how swat team advisors for the film related a similar true incident in toronto where a man henry masuka took an er. Unfortunately, johns insurance wont cover his sons transplant. How long do you suppose john qs prison sentence was. The novel had previously been adapted into a feature film in 1987.
As a rule, its not a good idea to pick up a gun, take over the emergency room of a hospital and threaten to kill your familys cardiac surgeon. The purpose of the film was to raise the many issues surrounding poor health care in the united states, and even less empathy from hospital administration and insurance companies. Even though its based on a true story, bravos dirty john has taken some liberties with the story for their adaptation. True story of ravindra kaushik, raw agent, that inspired john abrahams character in romeo akbar walter. People who have watched the movie john q have often wondered if it is based on a real life story. I am speaking of the main character in the film john q. Feb 21, 2002 john is still inside the hospital, dressed in scrubs so he can make sure his sons operation goes smoothly. The film tells the story of john quincy archibald denzel washington, a father and husband whose son is diagnosed with an enlarged heart and finds out he is unable to receive a transplant because hmo insurance will not cover it, before he decides. With denzel washington in the lead, it single handily saves this film from a being a bad film. All of these problems betray an underlying dramatic failure in john qs story. Denzel washington plays john q archibald, a factory worker and regular guy who. Review of john q essay sample john q is an emotionallypacked movie that surrounds the unfortunate medical circumstances of john, played by denzel washington, and his son. Although the movie is is based on a true story, the film did not deal with the. The batla house encounter, also known as operation batla house, took place on september 19, 2008.
I can relate to the story, because i know my father will do anything for me. John has been demoted to a parttime employee at his job and his wifes car has been repossessed. It is so earnest, so overwrought and so wildly implausible that it begs to be parodied. Archibald denzel washington is an ordinary man whose life revolves around his family. In the movie, the title character was charged with attempted murder, armed criminal action and kidnapping. After a series of tests at the hospital, john is informed by dr. Real life john q robs a bank in attempt to pay for cancer. This movie was everything that i hoped for and even more. B when seeking a heart for his dying son and in desperation takes the er hostage. The antagonizing drama did provoke such strong reactions from its viewers as to make people wonder about the fictitious archibalds characters relation to reality. I was pleased with the performances, the plot was very well thought out by the producers, denzel washington completely played his role as john q. John q is an unoriginal, cliche, overly dramatic movie that even manages to rip off dog day afternoon. He was found guilty of kidnapping, a class 2 felony in illinois. The story is about two abortive landings by the americans in vietnam, called landing zone xray and landing zone albany.
For one, the current state of the health care system is put on trial in this film. The recent release of the movie john q has fueled a debate about access to health care in the united states. The film tells the story of john quincy archibald denzel washington, a father and husband whose son is diagnosed with an enlarged heart and finds out he is unable to receive a transplant because hmo insurance will not cover it, before he decides to hold up the hospital and force them to do it. John q is a good drama film that could have been much better. For movie watchers able to suspend their disbelief, identify with the human dynamics of the story, and tolerate a onesided caricature of health careparticularly with respect to hmosjohn q provides suspenseful entertainment. When his nineyearold son mike collapses on a ball field, the archibalds learn that he has inoperable heart enlargement and that only a transplant can save him.
Man on fire is a 2004 action thriller film directed by tony scott from a screenplay by brian helgeland, and based on the 1980 novel of the same name by a. You wont see that in the movie, and im not knocking the movie, but thats the way we knew it was the marshall plane. This movie is brilliant not just from the great acting but also because their theme is so real life. Does the story at the heart of the film square with real life. I dont know if its a real story or not but i salute the director for directing such a great movie. Unfortunately, john s insurance wont cover his sons transplant. John creasy is a character created by late author philip nicholson under the pen name a. Its based on the gripping book we were soldiers once and young written by the man who was there and in command, hal moore. Is the character john creasy based on a real person. Archibald, a father so desperate to obtain a heart transplant for his son that when his h. John rushes michael to a hospital emergency room where he is informed that michaels only hope is a transplant.
Does anyone know who the name of the real person this movie is based upon. The movie was shot in a group of provincial government buildings in toronto, ontario. Jul 30, 2008 the message for sasha appears just before the end credits. More drama added to politics of transplants the new york times. Aug, 2015 john q is the story of a working class african american family. This is a dedication to director nick cassavetes daughter. Titor made numerous vague and specific predictions regarding calamitous events in 2004 and beyond, including a nuclear war, none of which came true. While predictable, john q is gripping on a number of accounts. Real life john q robs a bank in attempt to pay for cancer treatments for daughter african diaspora news channel. You may even see john or jane doe popping into a game some time to say hello and wish everyone well. It gives us a clear notion of the duties of public servants, and private administrators with regards to ethical decision they face in the daily execution of duties in communities they represent. Is the movie john q based on a true story alqurumresort. Making matters worse is the fact that some of the twists in the movies story are fairly predictable. Is the movie john q based on a true story, according to wiki where.
The film says this is possible because the sons defective heart is three. Wikipedia this article from time magazine indicates that the. Consider his multiple charges, what would have actually been dismissed, if anything, and how they would stack. The last movie that denzel washington was in was training day, and i heard that was awful. For movie watchers able to suspend their disbelief, identify with the human dynamics of the story, and tolerate a onesided caricature of health careparticularly with respect to hmos john q provides suspenseful entertainment. Clarifying john doejane does friends, followers, and badges. If the movie john q is not based on a true story then who is sasha.
John q is the kind of movie mad magazine prays for. Psycholgy exhibited in the film john q free essays, term. John q, played by denzel washington, faces a similar conundrum to that of mr. Dirty john true story complete timeline john meehans real. Despite its preachiness, john q is entertaining and features an especially fine performance by washington, whose portrayal of a fathers desperation is very palpable. What are the true events that inspired john abrahams movie. The film tells the story of john quincy archibald denzel washington. Thus, johns own negligence also contributes to the problem he faces, not just the stupid bureaucracy of his hmo and the hospital. Archibald washington is an ordinary man who must face the fact that his health insurance will not pay for the emergency heart transplant that is his sons only hope.
The character john creasy is reportedly not based on a real person. In this film, denzel washington portrays john creasy, a despondent, alcoholic former special activities. Archibald was based on a fictional character played by denzel washington in the movie john q. Read more about this movie on, via the related link. The biggest difference is that debras daughter, jacquelyn, has been replaced with veronica, a somewhat bratty, materialistic firecracker played by juno temple. The character first appeared in the novel man on fire, then in two movie adaptations of the same name. Raymond turner james woods and rebecca payne anne heche, a hospital administrator, that michael has an enlarged heart and will need a transplant. A few years ago, we observed that some players could add john doe and jane doe to their friends and followers lists on roblox or award these test accounts with badges.
A heartsick fathers plea for health care the washington. Several times, characters say words to the effect that quality health care is a luxury of the affluent, and the. The purpose of the film was to raise the many issues surrounding poor health care in the united states, and even less empathy from hospital administration and insurance. I agree with its message that the richest nation in history should be able to afford national health insurancebut the message is pounded in with such fevered melodrama, its as slanted and manipulative as your average political commercial. It was true, he said, that the public sometimes considered health insurers as. Because of this john q is a awesome movie, even though it is predictable at points the movie will still pull at your heart strings. In this analysis, i will explore the ethical and moral values. John q 110 movie clip heart failure 2002 hd youtube. Archibald is a loving family man facing financial problems because of factory cutbacks. Although e john q is a fictional story, john s actions in the movie are criminal offenses in the real world. Are all of the characters portrayed in the movie real people. Based on a true story, freedom writers is an inspiring film about a young teacher named erin gruell played by hilary swank who chooses to work at woodrow wilson high school in long beach, california.
John q is an emotionallypacked movie that surrounds the unfortunate medical circumstances of john, played by denzel washington, and his son. Although e john q is a fictional story, johns actions in the movie are criminal offenses in the real world. The good news is that most of us will never find ourselves in quite the medical crisis the john q. Sony atv publishing, iricom, ascap, latinautor umpg, latinautor, and 6 music. And if boxoffice reaction is any indication, plenty of frustrated healthcare consumers have at least fantasized about doing the same thing. This entry has no mention of whether the story is true or not. Vowing to do whatever it takes to keep his son alive, john q decides his only hope is a desperate gamble, and he takes the emergency room hostage. Jan 06, 2015 john is soon a media hero, the focus of intense news coverage, even as police chief gus monroe ray liotta and hostage negotiator frank grimes robert duvall try to resolve the situation before.